The Scalpel Act Plan

DOGE walked past $1 trillion on its way to fire the meat inspectors

By Cheryl Kelley

Nearly two years ago, DOGE promised to find $2 trillion. Then it promised $1 trillion. Then $150 billion. It ended up claiming $215 billion. In August, GAO checked the receipts. It could not verify $34.6 billion of the $61 billion DOGE said it saved by canceling contracts, and nearly 2,000 of those "canceled" contracts were never terminated.

Meanwhile, the government paid people to leave, then paid again to replace them. More than 20,000 employees who took DOGE's deferred resignation offer were replaced by new hires in the same office and the same job series. USDA food-safety inspectors took the offer while the agency advertised for replacements in 54 cities. Consumer complaints about meat, poultry and eggs rose nearly 40 percent, to a 12-year high.

DOGE walked right past the real money on its way to the payroll office.

A small group of us, retired and current federal finance people, say we can find $1 trillion in three years. We know where it is because we spent our careers putting it there, under orders.

Start with the paperwork. Since 1993, Congress has passed eight accountability laws, stacked one on another, and repealed none of the first seven. Each law built its own machinery:

  • Time-and-attendance systems that exist only so employees can code their hours into reporting categories.

  • Parallel budget systems, staffed and maintained, whose whole job is to re-sort money the financial system already tracks into the categories each law demands.

  • Grant recipients do the same re-sorting with the overhead the government lets them charge.

Repeal the stack. Replace it with one report that reads straight from the financial systems agencies already run. Counting the grant overhead, we estimate savings of up to $200 billion a year. There is a second dividend: familiarity breeds contempt, and paperwork breeds more. Fewer forms mean fewer Americans who despise their own government.

Then year-end spending. It's the clearest lesson in why reform fails. Reformers have attacked it for decades and always stopped at the obvious incentive, use it or lose it. Their fix is to let agencies carry unspent money into the next year. It works. When the Justice Department got that authority for IT, only 3.4 percent of its IT spending landed in the last week of the year, against 12.1 percent governmentwide. That means fewer panic-bought lobster tails and grand pianos. But money that rolls over still gets spent. That's better spending, not savings.

The deeper incentive isn't written anywhere a reformer would look. It's written in our evaluations. Most of the CFOs and budget officers in our group are retired, because current employees take the Hatch Act seriously and won't speak publicly about a candidate's plan. They say that they, and everyone they knew in finance, carried a specific performance target: spend down your appropriation, often to within 2 percent or 1 percent. Miss it, and you fail that part of your review.

No database captures that target. You find it only by asking. Reverse it, reward the manager who returns money, and the culture changes one evaluation at a time. We estimate $200 billion a year would be turned back voluntarily. That's more than GAO's estimate of improper payments, because GAO counts errors and crimes. This money is spent legally and on time.

Our plan earmarks every returned dollar for Social Security. Federal workers are Americans with parents, too. Tell a nuclear scientist and an HR clerk that what they save will shore up their mother's check, and watch what they find.

There's a bigger lesson here, and it isn't about budgets. Irving Janis studied the Bay of Pigs and named what happens when like-minded advisers pat each other on the back: groupthink. Harvard's Amy Edmondson found the other half of the story. Teams with high standards and the safety to speak up learn. High standards with fear produce anxiety and silence. Too much agreement and you lose the tension that makes people argue their case. Too much hostility and you lose the trust that lets them do their best work.

This country was built on creative tension. Madison designed the Constitution so that "ambition must be made to counteract ambition." He did not design it for the branches, the parties, or a government and its own workforce to treat one another as enemies.

We call our plan the Scalpel Act, because DOGE brought a chainsaw. Elon Musk literally waved one at CPAC.

A little-known Democrat running in a red district on Florida's Gulf Coast has adopted the plan. Kelly Kirschner, a former mayor of Sarasota, has pledged to bring civil servants to the table to write the bill and to have the Congressional Budget Office score every number. Former five-term Republican Congressman Dan Miller has endorsed him, and so has Republican County Commissioner George Kruse. A poll his campaign released in September shows him statistically tied. He says the message lands because his district, and maybe the country, knows we've stopped listening to each other.

The plan as it stands is a set of savings categories and aspirational targets, posted on his website for anyone to check. That's the point. Ask the people who do the work. Then argue about it.

Cheryl Kelley is a retired federal budget official who directed budget planning and management at the Federal Election Commission and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. She helped write the Scalpel Act and has advised the Kirschner campaign.

Sources

Contracting and purchasing

Year-end spending

Contractor cost and oversight

Performance reporting and grants

Audits

See the Tampa Bay Times Article Published on October 21, 2026:
Here’s How to Save the Federal Government more than $1 Trillion |  Column

Next
Next

They Did Not Shrink the Government